Four tag types. All of them hang by a single hole and get knocked against whatever is around them, so the hole (not the card) is where tags fail. Filter by what the tag has to do.

Card, string or barb fastening. It hangs on a product for sale.

Your shape, stock and fastening, no standard tag fits the job.

Synthetic, numbered or barcoded. It identifies equipment for years.

Mirror hang, color coded, checked through glass at a glance.
A retail swing tag is part of how the product is judged, so finish earns its cost there. Foil or spot UV at the moment a purchase decision is being made. Asset and parking tags are the opposite: they exist to be read and matched, so durability and unique numbering matter and appearance barely does. An asset tag that has become unreadable is worthless however good it looked when new.
Two things extend a tag's life more than anything else. A metal eyelet reinforces the punched hole and moves the failure point somewhere else entirely. On anything handled repeatedly it is a small cost against the tag tearing off. And lamination does structural work here rather than decorative, resisting the bending and moisture that soften card at the hole. For long service, step outside paper to a synthetic stock.